Bret gardener or melky cabrera?

which is the better baseball player


why?


i will choose best answer 10 points



Gardner, he has speed, and good outfield range. He also had a OBP over .400 last season down in AAA so he can be patient, he has all the potential, so he needs to be given a chance, and the Yankees have a lineup that can enable a guy like Brett Gardner to grow as a player in the Major Leagues.




If I do remember correctly Cabrera was second in outfield assists a couple of years ago. His arm is amazing. We all know his capability, he has more experience, and has some great highlights. Gardners is also homebrewn and has great potential. Speed is a plus in centerfield. So flip a coin.




For the Yankees Center Position i take Bret Gardner because he has SPEED , He has great Defense and i have seen have good at bats this spring training i think if he can better Patience at the Plate then the guy will be good





he can be a Lead off hitter or hit 9th




I will take Bret Gardner he has so much speed and can take an extra base. He is also good in the outfield. Melky will be a good back up player.




I think Melky Cbrera becuase he has MLB experince already. He has good speed. He has good defence to




They are both horrible. I'm sure Yanks will replace them with an all star player who makes 15 million a year.




brett gots the speed, but melky got that and experience. brett is quick and contact hitter. im gonin with bretty boy




brett gardner